Home › The cycle and the six knots
THE MAP

A cycle that feeds itself.

Each problem pushes the next. For example: outages lead many to install solar panels; the grid sells less electricity; and fixed costs are spread over those who remain.
The full story, in twelve steps →
And it is squeezed from the outside:
We are an island with no interconnection, and all fuel is imported · Knot 1 → Federal reconstruction money arrives slowly · Knot 6 →
Roadmap to an Energy Consensus for Puerto Rico · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion
THE SIX KNOTS
KNOT 1 OF 6 · ISLAND AND FUELWhy does electricity cost more here?
25.7¢ vs 15.8¢
per kWh: average price in Puerto Rico vs. a typical state (12 months to Aug 2026). The average is lower than the 33.9¢ on the home page because it includes subsidized customers; the home page shows an unsubsidized household.
  • There is no cable to another grid: if a plant fails, there is no one to buy from.
  • All fuel is imported. 6 of every 10 kWh are made by burning oil.
  • On average, a household spends ~8% of its income on electricity; in the U.S., 2.4%. For a retiree with $1,200 a month and a $180 bill, it is 15%.
THE DILEMMA · How do we depend less on oil?
A. Diversify: gas, solar or a cable

The price: investment, long contracts and years of waiting.

B. Stay as we are

The price: every oil price spike shows up in the next bill.

Comes from the history: 1954–1982, refining in the south · 1973–1979, oil and subsidy

Sources: EIA; PREB; IEEFA. · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion
KNOT 2 OF 6 · PLANTS AND GRIDWhy does the power go out?
There are two causes: old plants that do not produce enough, and a fragile grid of wires and poles.
40 years vs 18
average age of power plants: Puerto Rico vs. the U.S.
  • October 2026: on 9 days generation fell short at peak hour. If a plant failed, sectors had to be shut off in rotation.
  • With the rate frozen, price was prioritized over investment: from 2012 to 2017, investment was 2.6% of assets a year, versus ~6% at comparable utilities.
  • On normal days, excluding major events, most outage hours (8 of every 10 in 2025) come from failures in wires and poles, which LUMA has operated since 2021 and which also deteriorated over decades.
THE DILEMMA · How do we get more electricity now?
A. Lease temporary generation

The price: ~22¢ per kWh just to produce it under the latest contract (canceled in 2026), before adding the grid and everything else. Multi-billion-dollar contracts.

B. Wait for permanent plants

The price: outages continue until new plants come online.

Comes from the history: 1989–2016, frozen rate · 2001–2016, political managers · 2017, bankruptcy and Maria

Sources: PREB; Bond Buyer; Puerto Rico Energy Monitor (2025, approx.). · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion
KNOT 3 OF 6 · PUBLIC UTILITYWhat was PREPA used for?
27 years
without raising the base rate (1989–2016), to protect households and businesses. The gap was covered with loans.
What was frozen was the base rate. The fuel charge does go up and down every 3 months: that is why your bill changes.
  • Besides providing electricity: subsidies, electricity for municipalities, and jobs.
  • Each new administration appointed about 200 trusted managers. The result: 10 executive directors in a decade and little continuity.
DILEMMA · Who pays for subsidies and municipal electricity? About $329 million a year (fiscal year 2027 forecast)
A. Your bill (today)

The price: about 2¢ per kWh for every unsubsidized customer, whatever their income.

B. The government budget

The price: about $329 million a year in cuts or taxes, or more if the discounts now built into the base rate are included.

DILEMMA · What labor model? (UTIER and other unions)
A. Unionized

Gives workers a voice and stability. The price: benefits and pensions in the rate.

B. Flexible

Less spending on benefits. The price: experience is lost.

Comes from the history: 1941–1972, public utility · subsidies on the bill · 2001–2016, political managers · 2018–2023, LUMA and Genera

Sources: CRS R49489; LUMA before PREB; IEEFA. · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion
KNOT 4 OF 6 · DEBT AND BANKRUPTCYWhat is owed, and to whom?
$9 billion
owed by PREPA when it entered bankruptcy in 2017. It is now in its tenth year.
  • Bondholders claim more than $8.5 billion (about $12 billion with interest). The Oversight Board offered $3 billion. There is no agreement.
  • Pensions were promised when PREPA had secure revenue. Today they have no fund: they come out of your bill.
DILEMMA · How much to pay bondholders?
A. Close to what they claim

The price: several cents more per kWh, for decades (up to 6 to 9¢ in CNE's highest scenario; on a $150 bill, up to $28 to $40 more a month).

B. Little or nothing

The price: more years in court, and PREPA cannot borrow to repair plants in the meantime.

DILEMMA · How do we pay $300 million a year in pensions?
A. Your bill (today)

The price: 1.9¢ per kWh, about $9 a month on a $150 bill.

B. Cut the checks

The price: paid by ~10,000 elderly retirees. (Freezing, so that no new benefits accrue, does not lower today's checks.)

Comes from the history: 1989–2016, frozen rate · 2014–2016, end of credit · 2017, bankruptcy and Maria

Sources: CRS; Financial Oversight and Management Board; CNE. · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion
KNOT 5 OF 6 · THE SUNHow far should we push solar?
1 in 7
customers already has rooftop solar (2026). 9 in 10 systems include batteries to keep the lights on during an outage.
  • Rooftop solar: from 228 MW (2021) to 1,666 MW (Sept. 2026).
  • When your neighbor installs solar, they buy less electricity. But wires, pensions and debt cost the same and are spread over fewer customers. The fixed charge rose from $4 to $8 in July 2026.
DILEMMA · How fast should we move to renewables?
A. Faster

The price: paying sooner for batteries and grid equipment. (LUMA estimates $900 million to $2.6 billion in transmission upgrades; part of them is needed on any path.)

B. Slower, or with gas

The price: tied to the price of gas and to a single supplier.

DILEMMA · What credit should solar owners get? (Today, the electricity they send to the grid is credited against their bill: this is called net metering.)
A. Keep it

The price: more than $600 million between now and 2030 for those without solar, according to a preliminary study by the regulator. The solar industry says there is no such cost.

B. Reduce it

The price: fewer solar installations and fewer homes that can ride out a blackout.

Comes from the history: 2024–2026, solar and a record bill

Sources: EIA; IEEFA; PR100; LUMA IRP; Gabel; Puerto Rico Energy Monitor (LUMA, Sept. 2026). · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion
KNOT 6 OF 6 · FEDERAL MONEYWhat money is coming, and why is it slow?
25%
of the $14.3 billion obligated for the grid had been paid out as of Feb 2026.
  • Causes of delay: federal reviews, slow reimbursements and disputes among the parties.
  • The controls respond to real cases, such as Whitefish (2017).
  • Up to $7.6 billion to make the grid more resilient expires in September 2027: whatever is not committed by then may be lost.
THE DILEMMA · Control or speed?
A. Keep the controls

The price: more time. At today's pace, the grid would be ready around 2041 (estimate), and part of the delay does not depend on the controls.

B. Reduce the controls

The price: greater risk of misuse of funds.

Comes from the history: 2017, bankruptcy and Maria

Sources: GAO-26-107772; Puerto Rico Energy Monitor. · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion