Other countries have already walked this path
Uruguay has no oil, gas or coal. In the mid-2000s it depended on imported fuel and on rain for its dams. In 2008 the government approved an energy policy through 2030, and in 2010 every party represented in parliament signed it as a state policy. It was carried out over four consecutive administrations from different parties and attracted more than $8 billion in public and private investment, mainly in wind farms. Today about 98% of its electricity comes from renewable sources. The country is now negotiating a second version of the agreement, with a 2050 horizon.
Sources: Wikipedia · Ministry of Industry, Energy and Mining (policy and signed agreement) · Inter-American Dialogue
Denmark has a long tradition of written energy agreements among the parties in parliament, with multi-year targets that are reviewed and renewed. The 2012 agreement aimed for half of electricity to come from wind by 2020. The 2018 agreement was backed by every party: 55% renewable energy by 2030, no coal in power generation by that date, and three offshore wind farms. By 2020 wind already produced about 57% of the country's electricity. The government presented it as a way to give investors confidence and continuity.
Sources: Wikipedia · OECD · 2018 Agreement
To decide when to exit coal, the German government created a commission in 2018 with industry, unions, environmentalists, scientists and representatives of the mining regions. In January 2019 it recommended closing the last coal plant by 2038 at the latest (and assessing in 2032 whether it could be moved up to 2035), with about €40 billion in aid for the affected regions. In 2020 parliament passed the laws to put it in motion. The agreement eased tensions but did not end the debate: for some, the timeline is too slow for climate goals, and the final negotiation took place behind closed doors, with little public participation.
Sources: Wikipedia · World Resources Institute · RIFS Potsdam
After the 2001 crisis, the 2002 Economic Emergency Law froze electricity and gas rates to protect households. What was meant to be temporary lasted more than a decade: the state paid the difference with subsidies, companies invested less, and in 2003–2004 there was a supply crisis. Argentina went from exporting gas (about $6 billion in 2006) to importing it (about $4.6 billion net in 2015). In 2014, energy subsidies were $20 of every $100 the national government spent and accounted for its entire deficit that year. In 2016 a new government raised rates abruptly, with increases that in some cases exceeded 400%; the courts halted part of the increases because public hearings had not been held, and in 2019 and 2020 rates were frozen again. Without a policy that survives changes of government, each administration has changed course, and the country's experts are calling for a state policy.
Sources: Wikipedia · Professional Council of Economic Sciences of Buenos Aires · Argentine Energy Institute (IAE Mosconi)
What the ones that worked have in common
- All parties take part, not just the government of the day.
- They are reviewed every few years instead of being set forever.
- Someone with the capacity to do so carries them out.
- The process is visible: what is negotiated behind closed doors is hardly convincing.