Home › What we have to decide
WHAT WE HAVE TO DECIDE NOW

Eight decisions, each with its price.

Each question has several possible paths. Below, two of them are compared, with their advantages and their costs. The challenge is to solve the short term without doing too much damage to the long term. None is recommended here.
This roadmap focuses on how to manage the power system over the next seven years (2027–2033), while new firm generation comes online. It does not seek to settle Puerto Rico's energy path to 2050.
WHAT WE INHERITED
DEBT AND THE BILLWho pays PREPA's debt?
PREPA has been in bankruptcy for more than nine years. Whatever part of the debt is not paid, someone absorbs. The courts have handed victories to both sides.
It is decided in these seven years, though its effects last longer.
Who has to agree? Decided by the bankruptcy court, the Oversight Board, PREB and the bondholders. The cost falls on customers, through the bill, or on bondholders, through a haircut.
Possible paths: customers, through a charge on the bill · bondholders, through a deeper haircut · the government budget · a combination.
Charge on the bill
For
  • The bankruptcy ends sooner and PREPA regains access to credit.
  • Fewer years of litigation and fees.
Against
  • Several cents more per kWh for decades (up to 6 to 9¢ in CNE's highest scenario).
  • Competes for the same money as pensions and reconstruction.
Deeper haircut for bondholders
For
  • Less burden on the bill.
  • Customers do not carry that debt on their bill for decades.
Against
  • More years in bankruptcy and more fees.
  • PREPA still cannot borrow to repair plants.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupWith a charge on the billWith a deeper haircut for bondholders
The futureenvironment and future generations MixedA charge on the bill for decades, but PREPA regains credit to invest. MixedNo such charge, but more years without credit to invest in the grid.
Lower-income households Pays moreSeveral cents more per kWh for decades (up to $28 to $40 a month on a $150 bill, in CNE's highest scenario). MixedNo such charge, but more years of bankruptcy and fees.
Households with solar Pays moreThey pay the charge, though less than others if it is collected per kWh. MixedNo such charge, but more years of bankruptcy and fees.
Businesses Pays moreThe charge weighs more on heavy electricity users. MixedNo charge, but the uncertainty of bankruptcy continues.
PREPA retirees Pays moreThey compete with bondholders for the same PREPA money. GainsLess competition for PREPA's money.
PREPA bondholders GainsThey recover close to what they claim (more than $8.5 billion). Pays moreThey recover less and keep litigating.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

PENSIONSWho pays PREPA's pensions?
The pensions of PREPA's retired workers are an obligation someone has to pay. The retirement system ran out of funds in 2023.
It is decided in these seven years, though its effects last longer.
Who has to agree? Decided by the Legislature, the Oversight Board, PREB (if it stays on the bill) and the bankruptcy court. The cost falls on customers, taxpayers or retirees.
Possible paths: the bill · the general budget · the bankruptcy process · a combination.
On the bill
For
  • Pensions for ~10,000 retirees remain intact.
  • A stable source of payment while the bankruptcy lasts.
Against
  • 1.9¢ per kWh: ~$300 million a year, about $9 a month on a $150 bill.
  • A per-kWh charge does not consider the payer's income.
Off the bill
For
  • The bill goes down.
  • If paid from the general budget, the cost is shared according to taxes.
Against
  • The Oversight Board says the general budget does not have that $300 million.
  • Cuts hit elderly retirees; the retirement system says the short-term savings would be small.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupIf it keeps being paid through the billIf not
The futureenvironment and future generations No changeAdds no debt and does not change how electricity is produced. Pays moreIf the budget falls short and it is covered with borrowing, as in 2023–2025, the next generations inherit that debt.
Lower-income households Pays more1.9¢ per kWh, about $9 a month on a $150 bill, regardless of income. GainsThe bill goes down. If paid with taxes, people contribute according to income.
Households with solar Pays moreSince July 2026 they pay it too: it is built into the base rate. GainsTheir bill goes down.
Businesses Pays more1.9¢ on every kWh: weighs more on heavy users. GainsThe bill goes down, though they also contribute if taxes rise.
PREPA retirees GainsThey receive their full pension: about $1,857 a month on average. Pays moreIf cut, the checks of elderly retirees go down. Freezing (no new benefits accrue) mainly affects active employees, not today's checks.
Government budgettaxpayers No changeDoes not touch the government budget. Pays moreAbout $300 million a year that, according to the Oversight Board, the budget does not have.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation. “If not” has two exits: cut (retirees pay) or move it to the budget (taxpayers pay).

SUBSIDIESWho pays the electricity subsidies?
Electricity for municipalities, their street lighting and discounts for lower-income households are now paid within everyone's bill. They amount to about $329 million a year (forecast approved by the regulator for fiscal year 2027; between May 2025 and April 2026 the cost was about $311 million). That is only what appears as a separate charge on the bill: since July 2026, discounts for low-income households and public housing are built into the base rate.
Who has to agree? Decided by the Legislature (the laws that create the subsidies), PREB and the municipalities. The cost falls on customers without a subsidy or on taxpayers.
Possible paths: the bill · taxes (the budget) · changing who receives the subsidy.
Collecting social assistance and municipal electricity through the bill works like a regressive tax: every customer pays the same per kWh, whatever their income, so it weighs more on lower-income households. Act 22-2016 called some of these subsidies an “unjustified and disproportionate burden” on customers.
The data, year by year →
With taxes
For
  • The cost is shared according to income, not consumption.
  • The spending is visible in the budget.
Against
  • About $329 million a year (forecast) must be found in cuts or taxes, or more if the discounts now built into the base rate are included.
  • Competes every year with other needs.
On the bill
For
  • A stable source for municipalities and subsidized households.
  • Requires no new law or budget.
Against
  • About 2¢ per kWh for every unsubsidized customer, whatever their income.
  • Customers with solar pay less of that cost.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupIf paid with taxesIf they stay on the bill
The futureenvironment and future generations No changeDoes not change how electricity is produced. No changeDoes not change how electricity is produced.
Lower-income households MixedThe bill goes down, but the subsidy has to compete every year in the budget. Pays moreAbout 2¢ per kWh if they have no subsidy, whatever the household earns.
Households with solar No changeThey pay little of that charge because they buy fewer kWh. No changeThey pay little of that charge because they buy fewer kWh.
Businesses GainsThe bill drops by about 2¢ per kWh, though they contribute if taxes rise. Pays moreAbout 2¢ on every kWh.
PREPA retirees No changeTheir pensions do not change. No changeTheir pensions do not change.
Municipalities MixedThey keep their electricity and street lighting, but the payment has to compete every year in the budget. No changeThey keep receiving them through the bill.
Government budgettaxpayers Pays moreAbout $329 million a year (forecast), or more if the discounts now built into the base rate are included. No changeDoes not touch the government budget.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

WHAT IS URGENT
OUTAGES AND RECONSTRUCTIONWhat matters more when spending federal grid money: speed or controls?
Of about $14.3 billion in federal funds for the grid, roughly 25% has been paid out. Each control (environmental, cost and contract reviews) protects something and also adds time. What kind of grid to invest in is also still to be decided.
The scope of this decision: much of the delay depends on federal rules and staffing (FEMA's reviews, for example), which are not decided in Puerto Rico. What is decided here: who sets the priorities for the work, who fronts the money while reimbursement arrives, and what local charges are levied on the work. At today's pace, the grid would be rebuilt around 2041 (estimate).
Who has to agree? Decided by FEMA and other federal agencies (the rules), the Government of Puerto Rico (COR3 and PREPA), the Oversight Board and the operators (LUMA and Genera). The cost falls on customers: more years of outages or more risk of misuse of the money.
Possible paths: keep today's controls · simplify some controls · change what the money is invested in.
Simplify controls
For
  • The grid is rebuilt faster.
  • Less risk of losing up to $7.6 billion that expires in Sept. 2027.
Against
  • Greater risk of misuse of funds (as with Whitefish in 2017).
  • It does not depend on PR alone: FEMA and the Oversight Board have to agree.
Keep the controls
For
  • Protects the money against irregularities.
  • Responds to real cases from the past.
Against
  • More years of outages while the grid is rebuilt.
  • Risk of losing expiring funds.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupIf controls are simplifiedIf controls are kept
The futureenvironment and future generations GainsA more resilient grid sooner and less risk of losing the funds that expire in 2027, though with more risk of misuse. Pays moreSlower rebuilding and risk of losing mitigation funds.
Lower-income households MixedFewer years of outages, but more risk of misuse of money that belongs to everyone. Pays moreMore years of outages, with no solar or generator to ride them out.
Households with solar GainsFewer outages; less reliance on their batteries. Pays moreMore outages, though their batteries partly protect them.
Businesses MixedFewer losses from outages, but more risk of misuse of funds. Pays moreMore years of outages and of spending on generators.
PREPA retirees No changeTheir pensions do not change. No changeTheir pensions do not change.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

SHORT TERMHow do we cover the nights while new generation arrives?
There are night hours when generation is not enough to maintain the reserve: in October 2026 this happened on 9 days. New plants take years to arrive.
Batteries on the way: Genera is installing about 430 MW of batteries at six plants, with federal funds, and there are battery contracts next to private plants (the ASAP program) and with PREPA, several of them delayed. What delays them most is paperwork: interconnection studies, permits and approvals from PREPA and the Oversight Board. In addition, more than 80,000 homes already share part of their batteries with the grid during emergencies (about 500 MW enrolled in October 2025).
Who has to agree? Decided by PREB (contracts and programs), PREPA, the Oversight Board, LUMA, Genera and private plant owners. Also by homes and businesses with batteries, which choose whether to share part of their energy with the grid. The cost falls on customers, in the bill or through outages.
Possible paths: temporary generation · batteries · programs to reduce demand at peak hours · stay as we are, with load shedding.
Detail route: how do we add capacity? →
Temporary generation
For
  • Fewer outages from lack of generation.
  • Capacity in months, not years.
Against
  • ~22¢ per kWh just to produce it under the latest contract (canceled in 2026); multi-billion-dollar contracts.
  • If everything proposed is built, there could be excess capacity later (IEEFA).
Wait for the new plants
For
  • No money committed to something temporary.
  • The money goes to permanent plants.
Against
  • Load shedding and outages continue.
  • When plants fail, more diesel is burned, and that raises the bill.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupIf temporary generation is leasedIf we wait for the new plants
The futureenvironment and future generations Pays moreMulti-year fossil-fuel contracts and the risk of excess capacity later. MixedNo new contracts, but diesel keeps being burned when plants fail.
Lower-income households MixedFewer outages, but that energy (~22¢ per kWh) goes onto the bill. Pays moreMore outages, with no solar or generator to ride them out.
Households with solar MixedThey pay part of the cost; they already have their own backup. No changeTheir batteries partly protect them.
Businesses MixedFewer outages, with more expensive energy. Pays moreMore outages and more spending on generators.
PREPA retirees No changeTheir pensions do not change. No changeTheir pensions do not change.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

WHAT WE START BUILDING
RENEWABLESHow much renewable energy do we add over the next seven years?
Every society decides, at every moment, how much of its effort goes to covering today's needs and how much to preparing for what comes next. Renewable energy changes where electricity comes from, how much it costs and when it is paid for.
In 2019, Puerto Rico enacted Act 17-2019, which sets a goal of 100% renewable energy by 2050.
Who has to agree? Decided by the Legislature (the law setting the goal), PREB (the resource plan and contracts), PREPA, the Oversight Board and developers. The cost falls on customers, sooner or later.
Possible paths: how much and how fast: faster than today · at today's pace · slower. Where: rooftops and communities · large solar farms · a combination.
Detail route: how do we add capacity? →
More renewables, faster
For
  • Less dependence on imported oil.
  • Contracted solar costs about 13¢ per kWh on average over the contract (it starts lower and rises 2% a year), not counting backup.
Against
  • More batteries and grid equipment to connect solar must be paid for sooner.
  • PR has not managed to build at the planned pace.
At today's pace, or with gas
For
  • Firm electricity sooner, with gas.
  • Less up-front investment in the grid.
Against
  • Tied to the price of gas and to a single supplier.
  • Coal until 2032.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupWith more renewables, fasterSlower, or with gas
The futureenvironment and future generations MixedFewer emissions and less imported oil, but batteries and grid must be paid for sooner. MixedFirm power sooner, but coal until 2032 and more emissions.
Lower-income households Pays moreThey pay sooner for the investment in batteries, equipment and lines. MixedLess up-front investment, but exposed to the price of gas.
Households with solar No changeTheir own electricity does not change. No changeTheir own electricity does not change.
Businesses MixedLess long-term exposure to oil; higher investment cost sooner. MixedFirm power sooner; tied to the price of gas and to one supplier.
PREPA retirees No changeTheir pensions do not change. No changeTheir pensions do not change.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

ROOFTOPS AND THE BILLHow is the cost of the grid shared between homes with and without solar panels?
Rooftop solar reached 1,666 MW in September 2026. Those with solar use the grid less but remain connected to it; those without solar pay a larger share of the fixed cost.
Who has to agree? Decided by the Legislature and PREB. Also by each home and business that chooses whether to install panels. The cost falls on customers with panels or customers without them.
Possible paths: keep today's credit · change how the energy rooftops contribute is valued · add a fixed connection charge.
Keep the credit
For
  • Certainty for more than 200,000 customers who invested.
  • More homes can ride out a blackout, and their batteries already help the grid.
Against
  • More than $600 million shifted to those without solar between now and 2030, according to a preliminary study by the regulator (the industry disputes it).
  • The grid sells less, and fixed costs are spread over fewer customers.
Reduce it for new customers
For
  • Less cost shifted to those without solar.
  • More customers keep buying from the grid, and fixed costs are spread over more of them.
Against
  • Fewer installations and fewer homes that can ride out a blackout.
  • Lower-income households still lack access: a system with a battery costs ~$30,000.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupIf the same credit is keptIf it is reduced for new customers
The futureenvironment and future generations GainsMore solar and batteries: fewer emissions and more homes that can ride out a blackout. Pays moreFewer new installations.
Lower-income households To be determinedA preliminary study by the regulator estimates more than $600 million shifting to those without solar between now and 2030; the solar industry says there is no such cost. To be determinedDepends on whether that cost shift exists.
Households with solar GainsThey keep the credit they based their numbers on. No changeExisting solar owners are unaffected if the cut applies only to new customers.
Businesses MixedThose with solar gain; for those without, it depends on whether there is a cost shift. MixedThose without solar pay less; installing pays off less.
PREPA retirees No changeTheir pensions do not change. No changeTheir pensions do not change.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more · ? to be determined, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

WHO OPERATESWho operates the power system, and who oversees it?
Today private companies operate under contract, and the Energy Bureau provides oversight.
It is decided in these seven years, though its effects last longer.
Who has to agree? Decided by the government (the Public-Private Partnerships Authority and PREPA), the Oversight Board, the Legislature and PREB, which oversees. The cost falls on customers, and on LUMA and Genera if their contracts change or end.
Possible paths: private operators under contract · PREPA · a new public entity. In each case: who oversees, and with what public participation.
Private operators under contracttoday, LUMA and Genera
For
  • Avoids an exit cost of $1.3 billion or more, according to LUMA (the government disputes it).
  • PREPA now has few employees to resume operations.
Against
  • Performance is disputed: more outage minutes per customer than before LUMA, though fewer interruptions.
  • Long contracts that are hard to change.
PREPA
For
  • More direct public control.
  • Responds to dissatisfaction with the service.
Against
  • Exit cost and litigation: LUMA claims $4.5 billion or more in damages.
  • Someone has to be ready to run the grid the next day.
Who gains and who pays?
GroupIf private operators under contract continueIf PREPA operates again
The futureenvironment and future generations MixedContinuity, but long contracts that are hard to change. MixedMore public control, but exit cost and litigation.
Lower-income households MixedNo exit cost; service performance is disputed. Pays moreRisk of paying the exit cost ($1.3 billion or more according to LUMA; the government disputes it) and of a difficult transition.
Households with solar MixedSame as other customers. Pays moreSame as other customers.
Businesses MixedService continuity; performance is disputed. Pays moreUncertainty during the transition.
PREPA retirees No changeTheir pensions do not change. No changeTheir pensions do not change.

▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.

HOW TO REACH DECISIONS

Process topics to agree on

For these decisions to become concrete proposals, we also need to agree on how decisions will be made and to whom each proposal goes. These topics are not settled: they are presented as questions, with options of equal weight.
To be agreedWhat counts as an agreement?
If everyone is expected to agree on everything, anyone can stop the rest.
Options: unanimity · sufficient consensus (no key party blocks it, even if it does not agree with everything) · a majority of the participating sectors.
To be agreedWhat do we want to protect first?
Almost everyone wants reliable, affordable electricity. Disagreement starts when those goals compete for the same money.
Options: fewer outages · a bill that lower-income households can pay · the health and land of communities · jobs · not tying ourselves to commitments that are hard to undo. In no order: the order is what gets agreed.
To be agreedWhere do we start?
Not all decisions are equally ripe. Some possible criteria for choosing the first ones:
Options: what is decided in Puerto Rico · what can be tried on a small scale and corrected · what shows results in less than a year · what works with any long-term path.
To be agreedTo whom does each proposal go?
Many of these decisions are not made by the government alone. Customers, businesses, bondholders, retirees, operators and developers also decide, if only by accepting a cost or not. Each decision above says who has to agree.
Options: to the institutions that formally decide it · to those institutions and, at the same time, to the groups that would bear the cost · a commitment signed by the participating sectors.
To be agreedHow often is what was agreed reviewed?
No one can promise certainty seven years out. Reviewing allows corrections without starting over.
Options: every six months · every year · when a measurable goal is met (or missed).
To be agreedWhat happens to what does not reach agreement?
Disagreement on one decision does not have to stop the others.
Options: it stays under negotiation · it is tried on a small scale and evaluated · it goes to the institution responsible for deciding it, along with what was agreed.
Figures and positions come from the diagnostic; sources are on the Sources page. · Puerto Rico Chamber of Commerce · Draft for discussion