Eight decisions, each with its price.
DEBT AND THE BILLWho pays PREPA's debt?
- The bankruptcy ends sooner and PREPA regains access to credit.
- Fewer years of litigation and fees.
- Several cents more per kWh for decades (up to 6 to 9¢ in CNE's highest scenario).
- Competes for the same money as pensions and reconstruction.
- Less burden on the bill.
- Customers do not carry that debt on their bill for decades.
- More years in bankruptcy and more fees.
- PREPA still cannot borrow to repair plants.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | With a charge on the bill | With a deeper haircut for bondholders |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ◐ MixedA charge on the bill for decades, but PREPA regains credit to invest. | ◐ MixedNo such charge, but more years without credit to invest in the grid. |
| Lower-income households | ▼ Pays moreSeveral cents more per kWh for decades (up to $28 to $40 a month on a $150 bill, in CNE's highest scenario). | ◐ MixedNo such charge, but more years of bankruptcy and fees. |
| Households with solar | ▼ Pays moreThey pay the charge, though less than others if it is collected per kWh. | ◐ MixedNo such charge, but more years of bankruptcy and fees. |
| Businesses | ▼ Pays moreThe charge weighs more on heavy electricity users. | ◐ MixedNo charge, but the uncertainty of bankruptcy continues. |
| PREPA retirees | ▼ Pays moreThey compete with bondholders for the same PREPA money. | ▲ GainsLess competition for PREPA's money. |
| PREPA bondholders | ▲ GainsThey recover close to what they claim (more than $8.5 billion). | ▼ Pays moreThey recover less and keep litigating. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.
PENSIONSWho pays PREPA's pensions?
- Pensions for ~10,000 retirees remain intact.
- A stable source of payment while the bankruptcy lasts.
- 1.9¢ per kWh: ~$300 million a year, about $9 a month on a $150 bill.
- A per-kWh charge does not consider the payer's income.
- The bill goes down.
- If paid from the general budget, the cost is shared according to taxes.
- The Oversight Board says the general budget does not have that $300 million.
- Cuts hit elderly retirees; the retirement system says the short-term savings would be small.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | If it keeps being paid through the bill | If not |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ● No changeAdds no debt and does not change how electricity is produced. | ▼ Pays moreIf the budget falls short and it is covered with borrowing, as in 2023–2025, the next generations inherit that debt. |
| Lower-income households | ▼ Pays more1.9¢ per kWh, about $9 a month on a $150 bill, regardless of income. | ▲ GainsThe bill goes down. If paid with taxes, people contribute according to income. |
| Households with solar | ▼ Pays moreSince July 2026 they pay it too: it is built into the base rate. | ▲ GainsTheir bill goes down. |
| Businesses | ▼ Pays more1.9¢ on every kWh: weighs more on heavy users. | ▲ GainsThe bill goes down, though they also contribute if taxes rise. |
| PREPA retirees | ▲ GainsThey receive their full pension: about $1,857 a month on average. | ▼ Pays moreIf cut, the checks of elderly retirees go down. Freezing (no new benefits accrue) mainly affects active employees, not today's checks. |
| Government budgettaxpayers | ● No changeDoes not touch the government budget. | ▼ Pays moreAbout $300 million a year that, according to the Oversight Board, the budget does not have. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation. “If not” has two exits: cut (retirees pay) or move it to the budget (taxpayers pay).
SUBSIDIESWho pays the electricity subsidies?
- The cost is shared according to income, not consumption.
- The spending is visible in the budget.
- About $329 million a year (forecast) must be found in cuts or taxes, or more if the discounts now built into the base rate are included.
- Competes every year with other needs.
- A stable source for municipalities and subsidized households.
- Requires no new law or budget.
- About 2¢ per kWh for every unsubsidized customer, whatever their income.
- Customers with solar pay less of that cost.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | If paid with taxes | If they stay on the bill |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ● No changeDoes not change how electricity is produced. | ● No changeDoes not change how electricity is produced. |
| Lower-income households | ◐ MixedThe bill goes down, but the subsidy has to compete every year in the budget. | ▼ Pays moreAbout 2¢ per kWh if they have no subsidy, whatever the household earns. |
| Households with solar | ● No changeThey pay little of that charge because they buy fewer kWh. | ● No changeThey pay little of that charge because they buy fewer kWh. |
| Businesses | ▲ GainsThe bill drops by about 2¢ per kWh, though they contribute if taxes rise. | ▼ Pays moreAbout 2¢ on every kWh. |
| PREPA retirees | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. |
| Municipalities | ◐ MixedThey keep their electricity and street lighting, but the payment has to compete every year in the budget. | ● No changeThey keep receiving them through the bill. |
| Government budgettaxpayers | ▼ Pays moreAbout $329 million a year (forecast), or more if the discounts now built into the base rate are included. | ● No changeDoes not touch the government budget. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.
OUTAGES AND RECONSTRUCTIONWhat matters more when spending federal grid money: speed or controls?
- The grid is rebuilt faster.
- Less risk of losing up to $7.6 billion that expires in Sept. 2027.
- Greater risk of misuse of funds (as with Whitefish in 2017).
- It does not depend on PR alone: FEMA and the Oversight Board have to agree.
- Protects the money against irregularities.
- Responds to real cases from the past.
- More years of outages while the grid is rebuilt.
- Risk of losing expiring funds.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | If controls are simplified | If controls are kept |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ▲ GainsA more resilient grid sooner and less risk of losing the funds that expire in 2027, though with more risk of misuse. | ▼ Pays moreSlower rebuilding and risk of losing mitigation funds. |
| Lower-income households | ◐ MixedFewer years of outages, but more risk of misuse of money that belongs to everyone. | ▼ Pays moreMore years of outages, with no solar or generator to ride them out. |
| Households with solar | ▲ GainsFewer outages; less reliance on their batteries. | ▼ Pays moreMore outages, though their batteries partly protect them. |
| Businesses | ◐ MixedFewer losses from outages, but more risk of misuse of funds. | ▼ Pays moreMore years of outages and of spending on generators. |
| PREPA retirees | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.
SHORT TERMHow do we cover the nights while new generation arrives?
- Fewer outages from lack of generation.
- Capacity in months, not years.
- ~22¢ per kWh just to produce it under the latest contract (canceled in 2026); multi-billion-dollar contracts.
- If everything proposed is built, there could be excess capacity later (IEEFA).
- No money committed to something temporary.
- The money goes to permanent plants.
- Load shedding and outages continue.
- When plants fail, more diesel is burned, and that raises the bill.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | If temporary generation is leased | If we wait for the new plants |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ▼ Pays moreMulti-year fossil-fuel contracts and the risk of excess capacity later. | ◐ MixedNo new contracts, but diesel keeps being burned when plants fail. |
| Lower-income households | ◐ MixedFewer outages, but that energy (~22¢ per kWh) goes onto the bill. | ▼ Pays moreMore outages, with no solar or generator to ride them out. |
| Households with solar | ◐ MixedThey pay part of the cost; they already have their own backup. | ● No changeTheir batteries partly protect them. |
| Businesses | ◐ MixedFewer outages, with more expensive energy. | ▼ Pays moreMore outages and more spending on generators. |
| PREPA retirees | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.
RENEWABLESHow much renewable energy do we add over the next seven years?
- Less dependence on imported oil.
- Contracted solar costs about 13¢ per kWh on average over the contract (it starts lower and rises 2% a year), not counting backup.
- More batteries and grid equipment to connect solar must be paid for sooner.
- PR has not managed to build at the planned pace.
- Firm electricity sooner, with gas.
- Less up-front investment in the grid.
- Tied to the price of gas and to a single supplier.
- Coal until 2032.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | With more renewables, faster | Slower, or with gas |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ◐ MixedFewer emissions and less imported oil, but batteries and grid must be paid for sooner. | ◐ MixedFirm power sooner, but coal until 2032 and more emissions. |
| Lower-income households | ▼ Pays moreThey pay sooner for the investment in batteries, equipment and lines. | ◐ MixedLess up-front investment, but exposed to the price of gas. |
| Households with solar | ● No changeTheir own electricity does not change. | ● No changeTheir own electricity does not change. |
| Businesses | ◐ MixedLess long-term exposure to oil; higher investment cost sooner. | ◐ MixedFirm power sooner; tied to the price of gas and to one supplier. |
| PREPA retirees | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.
ROOFTOPS AND THE BILLHow is the cost of the grid shared between homes with and without solar panels?
- Certainty for more than 200,000 customers who invested.
- More homes can ride out a blackout, and their batteries already help the grid.
- More than $600 million shifted to those without solar between now and 2030, according to a preliminary study by the regulator (the industry disputes it).
- The grid sells less, and fixed costs are spread over fewer customers.
- Less cost shifted to those without solar.
- More customers keep buying from the grid, and fixed costs are spread over more of them.
- Fewer installations and fewer homes that can ride out a blackout.
- Lower-income households still lack access: a system with a battery costs ~$30,000.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | If the same credit is kept | If it is reduced for new customers |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ▲ GainsMore solar and batteries: fewer emissions and more homes that can ride out a blackout. | ▼ Pays moreFewer new installations. |
| Lower-income households | ? To be determinedA preliminary study by the regulator estimates more than $600 million shifting to those without solar between now and 2030; the solar industry says there is no such cost. | ? To be determinedDepends on whether that cost shift exists. |
| Households with solar | ▲ GainsThey keep the credit they based their numbers on. | ● No changeExisting solar owners are unaffected if the cut applies only to new customers. |
| Businesses | ◐ MixedThose with solar gain; for those without, it depends on whether there is a cost shift. | ◐ MixedThose without solar pay less; installing pays off less. |
| PREPA retirees | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more · ? to be determined, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.
WHO OPERATESWho operates the power system, and who oversees it?
- Avoids an exit cost of $1.3 billion or more, according to LUMA (the government disputes it).
- PREPA now has few employees to resume operations.
- Performance is disputed: more outage minutes per customer than before LUMA, though fewer interruptions.
- Long contracts that are hard to change.
- More direct public control.
- Responds to dissatisfaction with the service.
- Exit cost and litigation: LUMA claims $4.5 billion or more in damages.
- Someone has to be ready to run the grid the next day.
Who gains and who pays?
| Group | If private operators under contract continue | If PREPA operates again |
|---|---|---|
| The futureenvironment and future generations | ◐ MixedContinuity, but long contracts that are hard to change. | ◐ MixedMore public control, but exit cost and litigation. |
| Lower-income households | ◐ MixedNo exit cost; service performance is disputed. | ▼ Pays moreRisk of paying the exit cost ($1.3 billion or more according to LUMA; the government disputes it) and of a difficult transition. |
| Households with solar | ◐ MixedSame as other customers. | ▼ Pays moreSame as other customers. |
| Businesses | ◐ MixedService continuity; performance is disputed. | ▼ Pays moreUncertainty during the transition. |
| PREPA retirees | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. | ● No changeTheir pensions do not change. |
▲ gains · ● no change · ◐ mixed · ▼ pays more, comparing one path with the other. This is a qualitative reading, not a calculation.